Archive for category Jewish Unity

Balancing the Scales of Freedom

Originally published in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch the week after 9/11, between Rosh HaShonah and Yom Kippur.

 

It was Judgment Day — exactly one week after the World Trade Center buildings collapsed and so many illusions along with them.

 

“Judgment Day” is the expression found in the traditional liturgy for Rosh HaShonah, the first day of the Jewish new year.  And as I stood in the midst of the congregation intoning the High Holiday prayers, the vision of exploding passenger planes and twin towers crumbling to dust hovered before my eyes.

 

On Rosh HaShonah we will be inscribed … who will live and who will die … who by water and who by fire … who by storm and who by plague … Who will have peace and who will suffer … who will be cast down and who will be exalted.

 

The judgment upon Jews became kinder after the United States opened her doors to us a century ago.  Where no one else would have us, America took us in, allowing us to live both as Americans and as Jews without persecution. 

 

Yet for all that, American Jews often feel torn by opposing cultural forces, especially approaching our Day of Judgment in a society where there is no greater sin than “judgmentalism.” 

 

Without judgment, however, society cannot endure.  As good citizens we must judge others – not based on race or religion but upon actions and behavior.  And we must judge ourselves as well, by constantly reexamining our motives and our prejudices and our values and our goals.  To condemn even this kind of judgment as a threat to freedom is to retreat from our responsibility to discern right from wrong; it is to embrace the illusion of absolute theoretical freedom – moral anarchy – which is in reality no freedom at all.

 

September 11 brought us face to face with moral anarchy in the form of incomprehensible evil.  Perhaps the first step toward confronting it is to remind ourselves that freedom is not a right – it is a privilege, and privileges carry with them obligations that are often inconvenient and occasionally painful.  When Thomas Jefferson wrote that the tree of liberty must sometimes be refreshed with the blood of patriots, he warned that the threat against freedom can only be met by not taking freedom for granted.

 

Freedom is not democratic, as less than a score of suicidal zealots understood when they commandeered four transcontinental airliners.  The duties of freedom are non-negotiable, as New York firefighters and policemen understood when they rushed into crumbling skyscrapers.  And the rules of freedom cannot always be legislated:  sometimes we have to choose between necessary evils, as the passengers aboard United Airlines flight 93 understood when they drove their plane into a Pennsylvania field.

 

These are the kinds of judgments we must make, every day and every year, to preserve our society, all the more so in a nation built out of so many cultures and beliefs as ours.  Every freedom of the individual cannot be permitted if it threatens the collective, nor can every interest of the collective be observed if it oppresses the individual.  But when we share the collective will to make our society stable and secure, then the individual will set aside his personal freedoms for the national good and the nation will bend over backward to protect individual freedom. 

 

This is the mark of a great civilization, and it rests upon an informed and devoted citizenry prepared to debate, sometimes passionately but always civilly, the moral direction of our collective journey.

 

This Rosh HaShonah I stood shoulder to shoulder with friends and neighbors singing ancient liturgical poems in praise of our Creator, just as so many Americans stood together the week before singing “G-d Bless America.”  There were no agendas, no politics, no grudges, no rivalries.  All of a sudden we were one nation, indivisible, a people with one noble history and many noble ideals whose differences vanished in the shadow of our many common values and common goals.

 

As the Jews have had ample opportunity to learn, now America has learned that nothing brings us together like a common enemy.  What we have yet to learn is how to continue to stand together even in times of peace.

Leave a comment

The Continuing Battle Against the Ego

As we enter the month of Elul and begin thinking abou the approach of Rosh HaShonah — the Day of Judgment — nothing provides more impetus for self-reflection than the awareness that the Almighty conducts Himself toward us the way we conduct ourselves toward others.  Here is an example of how nothing can be harder, and how nothing can be easier.  This is the kind of hope and change we ought to be thinking about.

1 Comment

Truth and Faithfulness — Shabbos Chazon

Mercy and justice.  Reason and intuition.  Truth and faithfulness.  These are the qualities that the ba’alei machshava, the teachers of profound insight and mysticism, associate with the two aspects of creation — male and female.  The more overt and external qualities describe masculinity, where the more subtle and internal qualities describe femininity.

 

Justice derives from the intuitive recognition that everything in creation ultimately conforms to the will of the Creator of all; mercy derives from the reasoned conclusion that the function of free will is to influence the world in which we live.  Logic dictates that life is an active search for truth, where faithfulness dictates patience and restraint.  In the evening prayer, as we conclude our reaffirmation of our national mission through the recitation of Shema Yisroel, we immediately assert emes v’emunah kol zos — true and faithful is all this [that we have just declared].  Either one without the other is not sufficient; male or female by itself is incomplete.

 

When Adam and Chava (Eve) transgressed the word of G-d in Eden, Adam betrayed his Creator through misuse of his inclination toward truth by rationalizing his decision to eat from the forbidden fruit, where Chava betrayed her Creator by failing to be faithful to the mission that had been given her.  Created perfect and immortal, man and woman forfeited immortality and would have to begin the long process of working their way back to perfection.

 

Consequently, Adam was punished through a curse upon the earth:  by the sweat of your brow shall you eat bread.  Already assigned the more active role, Adam and his male descendants would have to toil merely to survive; spiritual achievement and perfection would not proceed naturally as they would have according to the original design.

 

Chava was punished through a curse upon her capacity to produce the next generation:  in pain will you bear children.  Moreover, the passive role assigned her would become even more pronounced:  Your passion will be for your husband, and he will have dominion over you.  The sign of Chava’s transgression would be the blood of niddah, her monthly cycle, symbolizing the death she had brought into the world by breaking faith.

 

This Shabbos, which precedes the week of Tisha B’av and our observance of national mourning, is called Shabbos Chazon after the opening words of the Haftorah, the weekly reading from the Prophets.  Scripture describes the prophet Isaiah’s vision of the Jews’ suffering in and ultimate redemption from exile.  Says the prophet in the name of the Almighty:  [I]f your sins will be like scarlet, they will become white like snow…

 

The Chassidic classic Me’or VaShemesh offers a deeper insight into the accentuated passivity imposed upon Chava and manifested through the blood of niddah.  Because G-d always prepares the cure before the affliction, He built into the system of biology the means for rectification.  When a woman conceives, the blood of niddah stops; after she gives birth, the flow of blood does not immediately resume but is replaced by the production of milk to sustain her nursing child.  The scarlet of sin becomes transformed into whiteness like snow as the woman, condemned to increased passivity by the first woman’s misdeed, now becomes an active participant in producing and nurturing the future of mankind.

 

When we become absorbed in our own agendas, our own projects, and our own priorities, we become passive in the sense that we turn ourselves inward with no concern for the world around us.  We become resentful of those around us whom we perceive as impediments to our success as they pursue their own individual goals.  This leads to the kind of corruption and divisiveness that brought about the destruction of the First and Second Temples respectively.

 

However, when we look beyond ourselves, when we define our sense of purpose as members of a larger whole and direct our efforts for the benefit of the community around us, then we become true givers.  By combining the logic of truth with the commitment of faithfulness, by recognizing that we cannot succeed individually but only in concert with the whole, may we earn the merit to see the scarlet of our sins permanently transformed into the white purity of snow and thereby hasten the rebuilding of the Third Temple, speedily and in our days.

Leave a comment

Reflections on Jewish Unity

Here are some thoughts, for better or for worse, on the struggle toward Jewish unity.  If the orthodox world has so much difficulty making peace with itself, how far away must be peace throughout the larger community?

 

The late Lubavitcher Rebbe once hosted Rav Joseph Soleveitchik and said that there, at his table, the neshomah (soul) of the Vilna Gaon and the neshomah of the Ba’al Shem Tov finally made peace after the tragic conflict that raged between the early Chassidim and their opponents.  Rav Soleveitchik replied that no, their neshomos made peace in Auschwitz.

 

May our generation make peace without, G-d forbid, such terrible impetus.

 

Jonathan Rosenblum on the Zurich Jewish community

http://www.cross-currents.com/archives/2008/07/23/turbulent-times-%e2%80%93-zurich-style/

Rav Emanuel Feldman on frum polarization

http://www.ou.org/index.php/jewish_action/article/10000/

Yours truly on the same

http://www.beyondbt.com/?p=573

Leave a comment